World news thread


User avatar
Vulcan 607
Major-General
Posts: 3671
Joined: Mon 31 Mar 2014 20:40
Location: Malton
Contact:

Re: World news thread

Postby Vulcan 607 » Fri 14 Jul 2017 16:03

Joint Franco German fighter program in the works
https://www.google.co.uk/amp/mobile.reuters.com/article/amp/idUSKBN19Y1FJ

This is the funniest part of the article

"It is a sign to the British. It means 'you are leaving the EU and we are driving forward. We are no longer interested in you blocking the EU on defense'," a senior German defense industry official told Reuters.

Said with no irony dispite the fact Germany delayed the typhoon increasing the price, avoiding a400 slots, not supporting talarion UAV and of cause taking bribes for the f104.

The French aren't much better having a tantrum over typhoon because nobody wanted their terrible engines. Trying to sabotage jaguar exports, developing the mirage f1 while it was meant to be building AFVG with Britain and then denying it when they got caught.

In all honesty the UK is better off working alone developing a jet or working with the US. The UK and France are still developing a UCAV though.


User avatar
Frencho
Lieutenant
Posts: 1200
Joined: Thu 13 Aug 2015 19:40
Contact:

Re: World news thread

Postby Frencho » Fri 14 Jul 2017 22:04

Meanwhile Président Empereur Macron slammed the Chief of the Defence Staff live and in color during his address yesterday...


Yeah the Chief of Staff who's doing his job, protesting against excessive cuts in order to have a functional organization (which is way overextended ATM) is part of his job, at this rate we'll end up like the British post Iraq, Afghanistan and Libya, in hibernation for 2 decades.
Now Général de Villiers threatened to resign.

I'm not in France so I'm about 10 hours late to news, no idea if he did indeed resign.

Pretentious move by Macron, he should take a good look at those WW1 rust cans, that's the state Leclerc in 10 years.

Pretty sure most Armed Forces brass can relate to this ATM

Wanna be the "Chef"? End that bullshit Opération Sentinelle, stop that silly nonsense of reintroducing a military service which would cost billions for no tangible improvement (conscript armies are better than professional ones right) effectively tax the rich at 45% (anything higher is excessive & counterpoductive IMHO) and reach 2% GDP in defense spending by 2019's LPM, otherwise shut up and go back to entertaining Trump in your mutual dick sizing contest.

Spoiler : :
Image

User avatar
D-M
Posts: 8585
Joined: Sat 23 Jul 2011 11:10
Contact:

Re: World news thread

Postby D-M » Sat 15 Jul 2017 01:11

Frencho wrote:Meanwhile Président Empereur Macron slammed the Chief of the Defence Staff live and in color during his address yesterday...


Yeah the Chief of Staff who's doing his job, protesting against excessive cuts in order to have a functional organization (which is way overextended ATM) is part of his job, at this rate we'll end up like the British post Iraq, Afghanistan and Libya, in hibernation for 2 decades.
Now Général de Villiers threatened to resign.

I'm not in France so I'm about 10 hours late to news, no idea if he did indeed resign.

Pretentious move by Macron, he should take a good look at those WW1 rust cans, that's the state Leclerc in 10 years.

Pretty sure most Armed Forces brass can relate to this ATM

Wanna be the "Chef"? End that bullshit Opération Sentinelle, stop that silly nonsense of reintroducing a military service which would cost billions for no tangible improvement (conscript armies are better than professional ones right) effectively tax the rich at 45% (anything higher is excessive & counterpoductive IMHO) and reach 2% GDP in defense spending by 2019's LPM, otherwise shut up and go back to entertaining Trump in your mutual dick sizing contest.

Spoiler : :
Image


Mec t'es sur canard PC ?

Anyway : https://twitter.com/philousports/status ... 3522251776
Image

User avatar
Frencho
Lieutenant
Posts: 1200
Joined: Thu 13 Aug 2015 19:40
Contact:

Re: World news thread

Postby Frencho » Sat 15 Jul 2017 20:38

D-M wrote:Mec t'es sur canard PC ?

Anyway : https://twitter.com/philousports/status ... 3522251776


?

User avatar
Frencho
Lieutenant
Posts: 1200
Joined: Thu 13 Aug 2015 19:40
Contact:

Re: World news thread

Postby Frencho » Sat 15 Jul 2017 20:40

Vulcan 607 wrote:Joint Franco German fighter program in the works
https://www.google.co.uk/amp/mobile.reuters.com/article/amp/idUSKBN19Y1FJ

This is the funniest part of the article

"It is a sign to the British. It means 'you are leaving the EU and we are driving forward. We are no longer interested in you blocking the EU on defense'," a senior German defense industry official told Reuters.

Said with no irony dispite the fact Germany delayed the typhoon increasing the price, avoiding a400 slots, not supporting talarion UAV and of cause taking bribes for the f104.

The French aren't much better having a tantrum over typhoon because nobody wanted their terrible engines. Trying to sabotage jaguar exports, developing the mirage f1 while it was meant to be building AFVG with Britain and then denying it when they got caught.

In all honesty the UK is better off working alone developing a jet or working with the US. The UK and France are still developing a UCAV though.


Airbus/Luftwaffe’s Next Generation Weapon System (NGWS) has been in the works for a few years, as in the project conception phase. Started as a German only project and they were begging France to join, as I mentioned it on my posts with you and Sleksa about the Rafale/Canada/Finland.

Thing is, I don’t think NGWS program will be successful. Germany sees it as a pressing short-term strike fighter program to replace their ageing Panavia Tornado fleet, so a 2030-2035 timeframe. France considers the NGWS as a Dassault Rafale Air Superiority replacement in the mid-2040s, seeing the Future Offensive Air System (FCAS) supersonic stealth combat drones will fill the strike role by 2050.

I mean, the operational needs are so divergent I can’t see this project working smoothly, this is basically Eurofighter2.0 but with roles reversed, France wants an interceptor, Germany a multirole. We know how that whole ordeal ended the last time.
The only thing that can salvage this is if the Germans fall in line under French leadership to design an ASF, and in order to replace their Tornados they buy interim tandem seat Rafale MLU/NG to be replaced long term by FCAS drones with custom German avionics & Luftwaffe standards.

Meanwhile, France and U.K have already done some quite successful joint R&D aeronautical projects, SEPECAT Jaguar, and currently two programs.
The first one being the low-key UCAV studies.

Meant for frenemies to share research on stealth drone protos Taranis and nEUROn.
There’s also the Franco British Rolls-Royce Turbomeca Adour engine prototype (just 41Kn) which powered the SEPECAT Jaguar and is being used on the UCAV protos.
The second one is the ambitious Future Combat Air System (FCAS), another next gen engine is in the works; 50% Safran (formerly SNECMA)/ 50% Rolls Royce, but much more powerful for fighter supersonic jet sized drones (they might try hypersonic too). First proto is slated for 2023 flight.

Also, to be frank, Franco-British cooperation tends to be very effective and it’s easier to work with the British than the Germans due to similar approach to warfare and operational needs (as in both actually project power abroad and wage war).

Therefore, Franco-British cooperation results in more coherent, functional and cheaper weapon systems.

Germans, I wholly distrust when it comes to defense projects.

They see weapon systems as high margin export products for rich countries, like if they were selling Mercedes/Audi/BMWs, injecting money in their industrial base to create/keep jobs in the Fatherland.

So, they just sell fancy marked-up weapons riding on “Deutsch kalitat” propaganda and then sell you a shiton of custom kits and upgrade kits over the years. In gamer layman’s terms so readers here get it, they’re basically Paradox hiding bugfixes and core overhauls within a shiton of DLCs, and rebranding it as "a service not a product".

In my opinion, Germans obsess with the industrial aspect of the project and not the actual weapon.

Why? Because they don’t go to war and haven’t in 72 years, if they join a coalition they “might” set up a base in the safest spot of the theatre and have orders not to ever leave it. I guess they don’t feel the same pressure to have cost efficient weapon systems to protect their soldiers’ lives, heh good thing they don’t leave base if their G36 melts after continuous fire in arid regions.
Then once Germans convince you into working with them on joint program, Germany ends up getting 50% of the workshare. Seeing their armed forces are a glorified kindergarten, they cut their orders by half and significantly increase the cost of the weapon systems to the warrior nations (U.K or Fra). Then they only ever bother to push hard for international sales if it’s a 100% German made system like the Leopards, Puma, Boxer, Rheinmetal cannons and their SPGs.

Has ever Germany bothered to push sales abroad for Eurofighter Typhoon or Eurocopter Tiger? No!

Eurocopter Tiger is a failure, entered actual operational service in the late 2000s, almost 20 years after its prototypes flew.
Then Germans wanted to put their own Mauser RMK30 30mm chaingun instead of the French GIAT DEFA 781M 30mm chaingun, so they spent time and funds designing that Mauser crap that never worked, so Germans Tigers don’t have a chaingun now (they can’t do CAS for infantry lol). To compensate the loss, they cut orders from 80 to 56, thus increasing prices for French & Spanish ones as collateral. If they were decent folks they would have avoided the sunk cost fallacy, abandon the Mauser chaingun and fit theirs with GIATs. Economies of scale would have lowered prices too for all the consortium members too.

Can’t blame the Australians for launching a tender to replace their 20 odd Tiger fleet, it’s so expensive and time consuming to maintain. Hell, no wonder the Germans wanted to call it Tiger, probably in homage to the overengineered WW2 heavy tanks.

A400M is a boondongle because the Germans piggy ride European defense project to acquire knowledge and skillsets their industry lacks. Mainly turbine and turbofan technology.

Germany demanded to have the lions share on the A400M turboprop manufacturing. They demanded this as a complete newcomer, MTU aeroengines worked on critical components (FADECS) instead of the low-key ones to learn the ropes, at the expense of Safran and Rolls Royce. So, they are the root of the goddamn cost overruns, delays and plane crashes. MTU learned a great deal, their workforce was well paid, and the rest got shafted with a shitty transport plane.
In short, they are training at Europe’s expense, while the other European countries get a marked up and deficient product which makes a headache out of any intervention, but hey Germans don’t care they as they can’t execute a military operation abroad anyways…

Compared all the previous to France’s and U.K successful cooperation on the Jaguar.
Or to SNECMA being humble and learning the ropes while working with Pratt & Whitley and GE.
They recognized they did not at that time have the level of competence of GE or P&W so they split 50%/50% the production with the French working on the easy non-critical engine parts while the hot parts were reserved for GE or P&W.
If it had been the Germans, they would have asked for 50% of the hot parts, even though they had no competence. That would have cost the program more, with the other party footing the bill and ceding to abusive demands.

Honestly Vulcan, at least the French SAFRAN ENGINE WORKS, it can power a 25-ton Rafale in heavy configuration (that’s 15 tons in payload) of the Charles de Gaulle's deck or proper runway.

The “terrible” French Safran M88 make the Rafale is the only fighter in the world so far capable of carrying 1.5 times its own mass on a regular basis. Unlike German parts imposed on European defense consortiums which end up never working as marketed and costing more, as I previously demonstrated.

Now when it comes to British defense industry Vulcan, reality is that since the mid-2000s it has been progressively phagocyted by the USA Military Industrial Complex. F-35 is the nail in the coffin. Current trend is that USA entities increasingly acquire more & more shares (Blackrock, Franklin etc…). If the trend continues they will own 50% at some point. To conclude, guess who’s BAE number 1 client, USA not UK…

http://www.4-traders.com/BAE-SYSTEMS-9583545/company/

TLDR; Germans just want to pillage French skillset and acumen in Fighter Jets, seeing U.K is now USA’s outsourced worker number 1 and Uncle Sam won’t let them pillage Brits anymore.

Bref, ça va être un merdier ce truc.
Last edited by Frencho on Sat 15 Jul 2017 21:17, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
Shrike
Lieutenant General
Posts: 4201
Joined: Sun 22 Sep 2013 04:30
Location: Central California, US
Contact:

Re: World news thread

Postby Shrike » Sat 15 Jul 2017 21:03

Wehraboos are a funny and annoying bunch. They think because it has a German flag on it means it comes with a some sort of seal of quality. Stuff like the G3s seem kind of meh, especially after Inrange mud test. Also the G36 is made out of the plastic used to make milk jugs and plastic bags like what were they thinking. Plus all that over engineered equipment in ww2.

Leopard 2 fanboys are funny bunch as well. They think their tank is super weapon compared to all the options, yet hasn't had much chance to prove itself other than getting exploded by incompetent turks in Syria.

User avatar
Frencho
Lieutenant
Posts: 1200
Joined: Thu 13 Aug 2015 19:40
Contact:

Re: World news thread

Postby Frencho » Sat 15 Jul 2017 21:31

Shrike wrote:Wehraboos are a funny and annoying bunch. They think because it has a German flag on it means it comes with a some sort of seal of quality. Stuff like the G3s seem kind of meh, especially after Inrange mud test. Also the G36 is made out of the plastic used to make milk jugs and plastic bags like what were they thinking. Plus all that over engineered equipment in ww2.

Leopard 2 fanboys are funny bunch as well. They think their tank is super weapon compared to all the options, yet hasn't had much chance to prove itself other than getting exploded by incompetent turks in Syria.


Then people wonder why I laugh and scoff when they say the Leclerc is under-armoured compared to the Leo2A/A5 and that 21 FAV is French bias, they prefer call me French nationalist when I tell them that not only 21 FAV is quite accurate, but that the Leclerc has better SAV and FCOS than Leo 2s...

Hell the Emiratis did not even lose a single Leclerc in Yemen, one took a direct frontal hit form a Kornet or Konkurs-M resulting in mission kill; driver killed, commanders legs gone.
There a two theories for the penetration, either it was a lower front plate hit or it hit a weak spot on the upper front plate (drivers viewport) and the scorching metal jet killed the driver and blew the legs of the commander. Also take into consideration that the 18 round drum is next to the driver and there was no cook-off!

Yet the Leclerc was retrieved, repaired and is now back in action.

User avatar
Shrike
Lieutenant General
Posts: 4201
Joined: Sun 22 Sep 2013 04:30
Location: Central California, US
Contact:

Re: World news thread

Postby Shrike » Sat 15 Jul 2017 21:40

I want a see a duel between the Leclerc and Ariete in wargame now.

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Frencho, Grabbed_by_the_Spets and 13 guests